Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Choosing the Right Media Mix

To Grow Your Business
 
Media Type
Industry
Budget
Product
Audience
Creative
Digital Media
 
 
 
 
 
Social Networking
 
 
 
 
 
Tweeting
 
 
 
 
 
Interstitials
 
 
 
 
 
Ad Words
 
 
 
 
 
Search Engine
 
 
 
 
 
Web Sites
 
 
 
 
 
Webinars
 
 
 
 
 
Traditional Media
 
 
 
 
 
Billboards
 
 
 
 
 
Radio
 
 
 
 
 
Television
 
 
 
 
 
Magazines
 
 
 
 
 
Newspapers
 
 
 
 
 
Trade Shows
 
 
 
 
 
Trade Journals
 
 
 
 
 
Direct Mail
 
 
 
 
 
Live Events
 
 
 
 
 
Sponsorship
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Many new media channels, ranging from social networking, tweeting and web sites to interstitials, ad words, search engine marketing have made advertising increasingly complex in recent years for businesses as a new dimension has evolved, known as digital advertising.  Add these to traditional mediums such as radio, TV, newspaper, magazines, trade journals billboards, trade shows, and direct mail; and clearly it becomes a difficult proposition to decide on reach, frequency and weight let alone the proportion of each and how together they can best create a synergy for your product or service. 

The choice of the type of media, and mix of media in advertising is predicated on the audience; their habitats, likes and dislikes. For example if your product has a young audience who use tablets and PDA’s primarily for getting their information then it makes sense to utilize a largely digital advertising strategy, but one always has to be aware of cutting through the clutter in a completive advertising space so using billboards at party clubs and ads in trendy age appropriate print vehicles can create a synergy with your digital campaign. Combining elements of both traditional and digital marketing channels will result in a more effective advertising outcome. While there can be many strategies there can only by one most effective advertising plan, like Lord of The Rings where “One ring to Rule Them  all”, in advertising one strategy rules  the mix of advertising channels. 

Like a finely tuned recipe for media, their frequency, reach and weight have to be proportionally adjusted depending on the objective for an advertising campaign, the industry you are in, the size & make-up of your audience and the type of product or service you are selling and the nature of your creative message. 

To make this more meaningful let’s focus the advice in this article a little more, by removing both ends of the company profile spectrum including small companies, (they do not have the resources & budget) and large companies (they are already the resources and budget and process) and focus only on medium sized companies, (which I would define as 10 employees to 200 employees). The chart below is a simple way of considering the process and helping you select the right media and the mixture required to achieve your goals. The chart is not a magic formula that allows you to blindly design a program by plugging in numbers etc. The chart should be cross referenced with the questionnaire which will be included in my next blog  - by seeking to defining how reach category relates to your product  ranging from the kind of industry you are in , your products audience and your budget it will help provide you with clues on selecting the right media.
 
A footnote to this is that word of mouth, sales and person to person advertising is not included. These, we are assuming, are in place to some extent for most organizations since they are more effective and less expensive although they reach a much smaller audience.
 
 Stay tuned for my next article which includes the questions that help you effectively define the advertising for your product or service.
 

 

Thursday, June 13, 2013

The Why and How of Advertising

With the advent of social networking, tweeting, web sites, interstitials, ad words, search engine marketing, etc., many small and medium sized companies have chosen not to advertise in the more traditional sense, i.e., print, newspapers, magazines, trade shows, TV, radio, signs, direct mail etc. or chose only one media channel rather than several complementary media channels. This decisions  are usually based on what kind of market or audience you are trying to reach and the budget. Unfortunately the budget usually decides what  and where you will spend your money rather then your audience.   

The basic strategy behind advertising regardless of audience or media channels remain consistent. It is just that there are more media channels today and less time to really understand their impact on our business. The purpose of advertising is to inform, persuade or remind potential customers that you offer the highest value product or service. It follows that before you design any advertisement  uniquely for your target audience you should know how you want to be positioned in the minds of the potential and existing customers. This includes knowing what type of media they use most often, the demographic and psychographic profile of your audience and ensuring you have strong creative that appeals to your audience. Show and tell rarely produces results and you need to appeal to your customers at the emotional level.

Now having said all that what are the basic steps in creating your advertising strategy?

 Develop Objectives


Once the decision to advertise has been made, the objectives of the advertising must be set. Typically advertising objectives are grouped into one of three functions; inform, persuade, and remind.

 Information advertising is used when a new product or service is launched. Done properly and ethically this type of advertising gives consumers the knowledge (features and benefits) necessary to make informed purchase decisions.

Persuasion advertising is the most common form of advertising. It is used to generate demand for a particular service in a particular market where competition for market share exists. The goal is to differentiate a product or service from others in the same market. Having a product differentiated in the minds of consumers can be beneficial since it usually allows for more pricing flexibility.

Reminder advertising is important once a service is established. This form of advertising can be especially important for firms that operate in a seasonal environment. You may want to “remind” consumers you are available to provide a variety of services throughout the year. The correct objectives for your advertising strategy can be easily determined from an analysis of the current marketing environment.

Select Media Channels


The media channels you select to get your message to the target audience depends on three elements: reach, frequency and impact. 

Reach is the number of unique consumers exposed to a particular ad at least once during a specified time period (usually a month or quarter).

Frequency is the number of times within the period that a consumer is exposed to the ad. A common rule is that most consumers need a minimum of three exposures before the ad registers with them.

Impact is a qualitative value of the advertising media. For example, will your ad have a greater impact in the local business paper or the local entertainment magazine?

To calculate total number of exposures multiply reach times frequency. This is known as Gross Rating Points or Impressions. A higher number of impressions implies more frequency, but tells us nothing about the potential impact of the ad on customer decisions. To measure the overall potential of an ad, including impact, combine all three elements, (R x F x I). This is known as the Weighted Number of Exposures (WE). A higher WE implies greater overall exposure.

Set Advertising Budget


You can set your budget any number of ways. Small businesses often set the budget based on what they think they can afford. This can be costly if the budget is too low or too high. Under-advertising may not produce any results at all. Over-advertising will result in some ads that do not generate sales. A better way to set the budget is to define objectives for the advertising and identify the tasks necessary to realize the objectives. Most advertising is priced in term of dollar cost per thousand exposures or CPM (the M is the Roman numeral for 1000). Higher impact ads usually, but not always, have a higher CPM associated with them. The media or media channels with the greatest combined reach, frequency and impact and a CPM within your advertising budget is the one to use.

Evaluate Results


Surprisingly, no definitive measures exist to evaluate the results of an advertisement on sales. The best way to evaluate advertising for small businesses is to:
  1. Keep track of the number of new contacts
  2. Ask every new contact how they heard of you
Now this last pint is very important since this can easily be tracked through web traffic analysis for smaller companies who do not have the staff or resources to follow up  on this. This will provide you with the information to judge your ad’s effectiveness in convincing consumers to contact you. As contacts become customers track their contribution to revenue. One new customer may be sufficient to justify a series of advertisements.

Conclusion


Advertising can be used effectively to increase sales. However, before creating an advertisement, know whom you want for customers and what type of media they use. Craft your message to communicate the features and benefits of your service that they will find most valuable. Focus on reach, frequency and impact and set a realistic budget. Be prepared for a lag time of one or two periods from ad placement to response. Finally, evaluate the results of your advertising to decide on the most cost effective level of future advertising.

In my next article I will tackle "Picking the Right Advertising Channels" of media for your company .

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Visionary or Caretaker: The Importance of “Finishing”

The ability to “Finish” or “close” a project is beginning to create more separation between those organizations that understand how to execute and those that struggle to bring the resources to the table that are required to effectively deliver a well-designed and implemented project.

Let’s face it, companies and organizations are challenged with doing more with less as the fiscal realities of the financial crises affect the way we do business. As organizations have become leaner so too has their ability to implement programs and initiatives in a well thought out process. As a result, small to medium sized businesses and organizations that seek out and utilize partnerships rather than internal resources can benefit and compete but only if their partner organizations are integrated as a trusted partner in the process.

 One of the most common gaps in my opinion in this new culture of partnership is the ability to promote and communicate one’s ideas to a broad spectrum of stakeholders and audience verticals. Once thought to be the strength of modern business, it has become an idea that has gradually faded.  I believe that we are exposed to so many mediums today in so many forms and places; we assume somehow that our ideas and initiatives will take on a life of their own, like social media where a simple idea can become a world-wide phenomenon.

 Modern day organizations often overlook what was once the most important aspect of a project, promoting an idea to the internal and external audience through a well thought out strategy with clear objectives, defined audiences through marketing, promotions, advertising and public relations tools. Partnerships are an important way of extending an organization’s resources and taking advantage unique skill sets to bridge the “Finish” gap.

 It is surprising that very sophisticated leaders and administrators simply fail to take advantage of these opportunities and partnerships.  Often, decisions makers don’t understand the ramifications or they undervalue existing partnerships, or are too busy to invest in new partnerships to fill this gap. They certainly give the idea merit by conducting a thorough planning process but somehow the “Finish” is missing when it comes to implementation.  

 I should add that a good “Finish” can take a long time – perhaps several years depending on the complexity of the initiative and the objectives of the project. While some things have gotten easier some have gotten harder and it’s the “Finish” that now demands a sustained plan in the face of competing media channels, new social interaction and growing entertainment opportunities…while we were worrying about the economy, the playing field  has gotten much more crowded.   

 This is at the heart of many a wayward implementation process. Whether it’s a company seeking to institute a new culture,  a business selling a new product or an organization promoting protocols within an industry the “Finish” has just become your most important mission  It will determine for most leaders their legacy of success and it will help define them as visionaries or simply as caretakers.    

 

 

 

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Public Sector E-Learning?


 
As an organization dedicated to  E-Learning and in particular Health Care E-Learning, we have a  considerable amount of experience  to offer our partners, dating back to the 80's when we were involved in a variety of innovative interactive learning projects. We worked with innovators such as Microsoft and IBM in creating interactive touch screen kiosks using laser disc technology. We then gradated to DVDs, web applications, online learning and now E-Learning.
 
 The interactive lessons and instructional design parameters haven't changed much in the over 30 years we have been working in the medium. We still have to make E-Learning interesting, engaging, personal,  story driven, intuitive, easy to use, flexible, accessible...well you get the point the list goes on and on!
 
I offer this background as proof of our experience and knowledge to add some weight to my thoughts in this blog because I am dismayed by the many organizations I have occasion to dialogue with about their approach to learning and the associated costs and responsibilities of learning and in particular, E-Learning.  In the face of ever increasing costs and the cries of budget cuts, traditional learning with all its additional costs, ranging from demands on time and effort, travel and inability to the validation of learning and comprehension or the lack of consistency of content, it seems to remain the medium of choice for middle management and senior administrators.
 
While many private sector organizations are beginning to understand the value of E-Learning , public sector organizations continue to support  a culture "old school" learning". Public sector organizations are either unwilling, unable or so unimaginative that they choose to remain moribund in a highly inefficient learning process. They continue to support the time honored process of workshops and seminars, that include travel time, paid absences from work, sandwich trays, high priced speakers, lack of accessibility by a diverse workforce, beverages and mingling with colleagues.
 
The truth is that one, all day work shop ( self-paced or blended learning) can be distilled into 2 hours of E-Learning and is available in perpetuity. The true savings really come in to effect when an organizations need not pay all the annual traditional training costs year after year. Unfortunately, there has been little oversight of public sector organizations and the drive to reduce costs through such tools as E-Learning. One can look at government public policy for almost any public sector organization and see  mission statement's that demand  the use of new technologies and E-Learning to help better train and reduce costs, but the lack of broader strategies in E-Learning has undermined these directives. 
 
Organizations have little internal expertise in this area and are bewildered at the decision making process and often choose to focus on technical solutions rather than implementation and content issues. The example I like to use is the phone, most people don't know how a phone works and don't care - they simply want to use it effectively. The same is true for E-Learning - too much attention is paid to the technology and the IT department and not enough to the administration and implementation issues that demand leadership and vision. E-Learning technology is relatively mature and you can select any number of solutions and be successful today, but success is not defined by the technology you implement but by the level of comprehension of the content and the change in behavior.
 
From 1997 to 1998 and 2006 to 2007, the federal government of Canada transferred $115.7 billion to the provinces for health care - 36 billion more than was needed to keep up with population growth and inflation during the same period. If the public sector is proclaiming there is no more money for health care then the only logical solution is that the public sector organizations and agencies partner with experienced private sector companies to help deliver more effective learning solutions.
 
Unfortunately many ( and I stress not all) senior administrators and middle managers spend their budgets in traditional fashion without doing serious cost analysis of current training strategies and the wide ranging effects training can have on an organization and its effectiveness.  We believe the time for  saying" Its not my job to train" is over, learning is pervasive in every part of an organization and it remains management's responsibility at all levels to ensure that policies, guidelines, protocols, requirements, procedures and the general pursuit of knowledge should be foremost in an organization, if its staff is to be effective and meet client expectations! 
 
 

 

 

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

New Media Project Management


Sound project management is a much undervalued skill. While it will help bring your project in on-time and on-budget – perhaps more importantly it will allow your project to incorporate innovation that helps differentiate you from your competitors. Since most projects demand one to one relationships to ensure the confidence of information and direction -  these “Janus” (The Roman God of Gatekeeping) or gatekeepers are crucial to a project’s success. 
 
There are some project management certifications and programs but few are attainable within the media industry especially given the fact that technology, developer skill sets and software toolsets change frequently. So how do we teach or learn sound project management skills in an ever-changing environment. I believe one of the most important ingredients is selecting the right kind of person. If we have very few classically trained project management experts in new media then we have to assume they are being created “on the fly” through the school of hard knocks.

 The type of personality required has to have some special traits in my estimation. He or she has to show a real willingness to understand the barriers, influencing factors and the strengths and weaknesses of those involved in the project (a willingness to walk a mile in their shoes).  The person must also have a broad affinity for learning technology but not a love of technology since you have to be very broad-minded and objective to mesh or mold the various pieces of a project into one coherent product delivery.  

 A new media project is a complex process that can involve a number of stakeholders that can range from third party vendors, technology suppliers, steering committees, non-profit organizations, partnerships, senior management and a variety of internal departments. Each may have different roles and stakes in the project and all must be satisfied to some degree with the outcome of the process. The following includes a few tips on effectively a  maintaining leadership role in the project while building consensus during the process. 

1. Gather information- learn as much as possible about the project and the stakeholders at the outset. 

  • Request client information: annual reports, newspaper articles, photos, books, newsletters, video, Broadcast news stories, magazine interview, industry reviews , special internal communications, written questionnaire, telephone interviews and employee interviews
2. Develop a clear understanding of execution of the project

  • Understand timelines & potential consequences of missing the timelines
  • Review skills of key stakeholders and or project team
  • ensure a detailed proposal is provided and approved
  • Ensure financing is in place
  • Document each step and all communications
  • Understand your barriers & obstacles: solutions
  • Understand all the deliverable requirements, who needs them and why
  • Define what mandate or authority you have to manage the project
3. Communication at all levels

  • Written documentation at each phase of the project
  • Restating client’s agreed terms of business
  • 1dentifying changes in process: approval, requirements, personnel, time and materials
  • When not to communicate: maintain project focus - politics, personality
 4. Provide a client with what they want - not what they ask for 

  • Understand  what is needed and rely on your experience
  • Identify problems early and act to provide a solution
  • Draw a conclusion: evaluate your work and those on your team
5. Deliver quality  & innovation 

  • No one will reward poor work delivered on-time and on-budget
  • Learn from your mistakes
  • Improve the methodology
  • Fear not when doing right
  • Challenge yourself 
6. Evaluate your project after completion and leave a legacy 

  • During the project create a process for tracking the effectiveness of the project
  • Archive the project assets for future changes
  • Ensure that one key stakeholder remains responsible for the project future success