Friday, September 11, 2015

Digital Strategy:Mobile vs Desktop?


 
Each device  has a different screen resolution and orientation
We spend a lot time talking to our customers about the relative differences & benefits of mobile versus desktop users, since we have our foot in both the development of web portals and eLearning. Most clients simply assume that desktop  and mobile users are accessible readily and that there are no additional costs in communicating to both platforms. Not true ... as it stands today, digital communications are not ubiquitous across both the desktop and mobile platforms; and as a result there are often hidden costs in developing content. 

Evolving and migrating technologies from one standard or format to another has been with us for generations. Many of us have experienced this in our lifetime, as we have moved from cassettes to USB storage devices and from simple gaming systems to tablets and smart phones. As technology evolves and capacity expands we seem to straddle multiple technologies simultaneously. Multiple media formats seem to co-exist in the marketplace at any one time; and this trend now appears to be some kind of “law of evolving technology.” I think the cost of communicating to both desktops and mobile devices has been obscured because of the similarity in the technology. In the past it was pretty easy to spot the differences because of the dramatic change in format, size and application.


 Hand held devices have varying resolutions and screen orientation to enhance the user's visual experience. This is at the heart of what is different about this evolution. It is an incremental and simultaneously specific improvement.  Adapting the visual look and feel of the communication  experience to the type of smart phone, desktop or tablet is not a transparent process. Our online digital communications are designed to interrogate the device we are trying to communicate with to determine its resolution and deliver the format that best suits the device. This often means creating two versions of any web site, portal or eLearning experience,and each has to be tweaked to make sure its is delivering the intended experience in most formats.


In the past we would have been eager to blame this on the manufacturer failing to agree on a standard or format but in this instance we have to take some of the blame. Each of us wants a personal experience, one that is unique and responds to our needs and as a result it appears that a variety of resolutions and orientation are going to be with us well into the future.  I am sure that with time, these issues will be resolved, where adaptive design can deliver a common experience on a very personal device using one communications, entertainment or advertising standard programming  language. But, that is the future - and for now…there are additional costs to developing for multiple formats.

Many organizations and business when planning eLearning for example, automatically include both mobile and desktop audiences. They do this because the media is awash in stories, studies and statements heralding the advent of the mobile user and their need to be included in any digital strategy. What is not being included or understood by organizations is the cost of communicating to each audience, including desktops or mobile, or both!  I think organizations have to ask themselves, do you really want people sitting at Starbucks or riding the subway using their phones to try and learn complex ideas. There are some practical standards that must be considered in the learning process that place some of the learning responsibility on the leaner. 

 I think we have to investigate the demographics of each group to better understand - how each segment uses these technologies and understand what value they place on the information provided - to help us understand cost/benefit of an initiative. There are some circumstances where designing for primarily a desktop audience is more cost effective for the type of audience, the content and the way information is being consumed.  This is often more cost effective when detailed information must be delivered and comprehension of complex ideas may be involved, especially when you consider that desktops still have a significant presence in office settings and sales continue to be surprisingly strong. Alternatively, retail web sites and broad product-driven web sites should be developed for both desktop and mobile platforms since customers demand  convenience and a uniquely personal experience. 

Don’t misunderstand me, mobile devices such as tablets and smart phones are the future and they continue to be a growing segment in market, statistics show they will surpass PC sales this year. But it will be some time before PCs are no longer used in offices` and tablets are used as the primary means of office productivity. 


So, when you are planning an online project, there are many circumstances where developing for all platforms makes sense. But remember, it all comes at a cost, if you’re developing learning strategies you may want to consider how delivering complex content on a mobile device in a variety of settings may affect our understanding and appreciation of the content. 

Monday, July 20, 2015

Brands: The Slip between the Cup and the Lip

Everybody seems to be in the business of marketing these days. From personal brands to product brands to service brands, almost every aspect of our lives are buffeted by some form of advertising that features a brand. I remember reading a prediction a few years ago that suggested that virtually every surface we interact with in the future will be a delivery medium for advertising and ultimately brand awareness. This is becoming increasingly true, as walls, sky, sidewalks, roadways, buildings, clothing, bodies, every nook and cranny of the online experience and product placements in movies and television, all increase the number of advertising impressions and marketing opportunities we are exposed to every day.

The baby boom generation, with its higher education, its message of change and a more liberal outlook has created an alphabet of echo generations that have taken “freedom of expression” to new heights through pervasive marketing. The freedom to market to each other on a global scale fulfills an unbridled desire for avarice that has been spawned by this unique time in our history as a civilization. Having said all this, does this suggest that this knowledge and sophistication - and this proliferation of marketing mediums translates directly into a more savvy, focused  society that can manipulate marketing and ultimately each person, to their own benefit? I wonder if we are not both abuser and abused in this new marketing-centric reality.  

A provocative concept if you think of yourself as a marketer (which you probably are in one form or another.) Unfocused marketing and advertising coupled with the ever changing market forces can result in ineffective marketing strategies. We often advertise to the individuals because we can, or to everybody even though we shouldn’t, to gain immediate results, often at the cost of long term growth and potential.    

What does it all mean? The main rule that governs successful marketing plans and their advertising offspring remain effective. “Design any marketing plan and advertising program around the wants and needs of your customer.” Not around the message a marketer wants to deliver. Here are some examples of marketing plans and some insights on how advertising that results from those plans may not be as effective as they should. See if you recognize these examples from your own experience?
  1. You have invested in new technology and added some new features to your product, so you develop an advertising campaign based on the benefits of the new technology rather than the how the technology solves a problem for your customer.
  2.  A marketing plan has defined a number of unique advantages in your product or service. You develop an advertising campaign that tries to highlight all of the benefits at once, creating confusion for the customer. 
  3. You develop a strategy that identifies a group of potential demographic audiences. You then proceed to try and develop a single message that reaches all of these audiences at once.  Audiences don’t connect with your message or your product because of lack of clarity.
  4. You recognize that your product is only beneficial to a small group of potential customers. You try and reach them by developing an advertising campaign that seeks to talk directly to that group in a place and at a time that they are not inclined to give consideration to your product or service.
  5. You fail to create trust in your marketing campaign by delivering the marketing message in a medium that does not engender trust in your audience. For example your ad is placed on Facebook of Linked In and your customers are business to business clients who get their industry information through industry channels rather than social networks. 
  6. You are in a very competitive marketplace and you need to differentiate yourself from your competitors.  Marketing plans determine that you need to use price differentiation and volume to help drive sales. You use tired and common advertising concepts  and get no response from your ad campaign.
  7. You fail to connect your marketing campaign to great customer service.  You make all the right moves, you create a specific message, you reach customers with the right medium, you begin getting good customer response but because of limited staff you don’t answer the phone on a timely and friendly basis and end up loosing many of the leads you create.
  8. You are an organization rather than a company and don’t really think you should have a strong focus on marketing. Your organization is chiefly focused on sharing knowledge and acting as a liaison with regulatory bodies.  You don’t survey your members regularly to help design programs that respond to their needs and you don’t bother promoting the value of your services and begin loosing members.
  9.  You are retailer that buys media space such as newspaper, radio and television because your product appeals to a broad demographic. You do not get any response from your program because the media outlet you have chosen offers to prepare an ad for you to help you to save money and put more money into a media buy rather than a carefully crafted message aimed at your audience.
  10. You develop an advertising strategy and then a corresponding advertising campaign and you expect results as soon as possible. You spend a considerable amount on it and now it is not preforming as you hoped. So you panic and change the program and/or reduce funding budgets before you derive data about the program that will lead you to sound decision making and success over the long term.    

Monday, June 22, 2015

eLearning Towards Organizational Success

Champion creative risk taking and engage learners 
and link performance to organizational and individual success.
Our company has been involved in developing eLearning since 2004, when we developed our first full-featured eLearning module. Since then, adoption of eLearning has been slow as companies and organizations have continued to invest in less efficient traditional classroom-style or lecture style training, with predictably poor results. Recently, we have witnessed an increase in the adoption rate of eLearning as a primary tool in training and development; but often the planning and implementation are tactical, and little consideration is given to the most important aspect of learning, comprehension. We thought we would take a moment out to share our insights into eLearning implementation pitfalls.  
  • Over the past several years we have observed many RFPs from companies and organizations and in almost every circumstance, the RFP were often primarily designed around the purchase of a Learning Management System (LMS).  Content and comprehension are generally viewed as an afterthought.
  •  eLearning content, as we have witnessed in many programs across Canada are often a patchwork of legacy content. Programs often include legacy web based content, video snippets, documents, PDFs and PowerPoint. In the rare circumstances where organizations are producing content they often do not have the expertise to product content for today's media savvy sophisticated professional worker.
  • Most organizations do not enforce a vibrant testing and reporting eLearning process.  In some circumstances this may be a result of mixed union and non-union environments, in others it’s a lack of commitment to developing a comprehensive learning strategy and in still other circumstances it is the result of not including learners in the learning strategy development process.
  • Many compulsory or compliance eLearning courses are simple and lack any creativity, and most skilled workers try and skip the content and go directly to the questions to get through the process with as little focus as possible. Most will cheat on the test portion given the chance, since there is little in the content to challenge them and programs often lack incentive to achieve and opportunities to share knowledge are virtually non-existent.
  • eLearning technology, while generally sophisticated from an administration and reporting point of view are rarely utilized to their full extent to understand the learner experience. Administrators stick to the same basic reporting criteria, pass/fail, completion score, name and department. Often learning programs are under-resourced and performance in learning programs is not tied directly to organizational and individual success.  
  • Many eLearning programs fail to incorporate the learner in the process. The system often does not include gathering consistent learner feedback on the experience in terms of their engagement or their ability to share knowledge among peers, as is the case in traditional learning environments. This is often a result of designing eLearning as an adjunct to existing training programs. They are thought of as a cost cutting measure rather than a new form of learning that is persistent.
  • Leaders in management groups, teams and committees often see and understand the value of eLearning and create mandates for implementation but implementation becomes a logistical or tactical implementation plan rather than a larger strategy linked to performance. Cost reduction becomes the number one driving factor in eLearning design and implementation rather than comprehension and organizational success.
  • Most organizations take a very traditional approach to a learning process by not championing creative "risk-taking" in the design and implementation of eLearning programs.  Little in the way of testing unique programs, lateral learning opportunities, or innovation is occurring in eLearning, primarily due to cost.  Creating management teams that consider efficacy as well as creativity, can have a profound effect on individual performance and organizational success.
  • Failure is an important part of learning. In most eLearning curricula and modules, the possibility of failure is either absent or minimized. Creating learning from failure can be realized  by creating higher threshold achievement levels, more complex information, more difficult questions, random test questions or checkpoint questions that allows the learner to gauge their understanding. Do not be afraid to challenge the learner but create additional incentives to succeed as well.
These thoughts and observations are designed to challenge thinking on current eLearning strategies. Just implementing eLearning is not enough …organizations and businesses need to implement learning strategies that are tied to individual and organizational performance results.

Monday, June 1, 2015

Words & Symbols, Plus Repetition

I recently saw this point-of-sale ad on a gas pump at my local Shell station. Other similar and larger cardboard point-of-sale ads trumpeted this new high performance gas product. I have worked for Shell Canada in the past with its Ultra 94 launch in the 90s. I wanted to point out that sometimes- too much is too much...even in advertising.  In an effort to promote the idea of power and performance check out the number of different but similar words used in this ad to say exactly the same thing...who said simple is better?
  • V - is a symbol representation more power than traditional 6 cylinder ( today's  vehicle engine standard)
  • The word Power speaks for itself
  • The word Nitro essentially describing explosive power
  • The plus symbol describes enhanced power
  • Premium described the best power
 Symbols and words, Plus Repetition do not always lead to clearer communications or create compelling narrative.  
 My purpose for sharing this is to make people more aware of manipulative advertising and the thinking (or not) behind it. I would be interested in hearing your thoughts. 
  1. Who the audience is for this type of gasoline?
  2. Have they crystalized the idea of improved power and performance?
  3. Is an overly simplistic approach an insult
  4. Would you notice it?
  5. Do you care?
  6. How does it affect you emotionally?

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Reverse Engineering the Business Conduit



It always surprises me to talk to decision makers and learn how they view marketing. They see it as a silo of responsibility within their organization, not really recognizing how marketing is integrated throughout the organization.  I have used an awkward turn of phrase here in describing how marketing is intertwined within an organization, “throughout”; and to trade on a quote from the Princess Bride, by Inigo Montoya, “this word does really mean what I think it means.” 

“Throughout“, talks to the idea that marketing touches on all the vital business processes within a company, ranging from the product manufacturing and  new products & services to customer and employee satisfaction.  Marketing plans and advertising strategies are defined by a wide range of factors. All too often business owners believe that marketing is a smoke and mirrors process that acts independently, usually on an as-needed basis.  Companies tend to put in place processes for evaluating their company or organization and fail to undertake an objective review that will reveal hidden factors that will affect company prospects.

Today’s customers have more choice, new technology is evolving daily and employee and stakeholder relationships are complicated;  and drumming up an initiative or a marketing plan to suit the demands of the moment may not  be the best way to grow your company. When I meet with clients and begin to ask questions, the business or organizational leader is not really prepared to answer the kinds of questions I need to ask. They see the process of marketing as an isolated component of their business, to be respected and addressed from time to time. They may have a process but does it really evaluate the company “throughout”?

Rather than have top decision makers determine a marketing plan, it is essential that the sum of the parts of a company influence how, when, why and by who a product or service is delivered and marketing can have a significant impact on this. Think of the process of developing a marketing plan as a conduit; now begin reverse engineering the company by seeking to understand all of the influencing factors along that conduit.  Start at the end, when a product or service is delivered to a customer, and work your way backwards through the process, evaluating all of the factors that affects the production and delivery of a product to a customer.

When you are developing a marketing plan, you should seek to uncover opportunity gaps by exploring the influencing factors that affect the “conduit”. This will include gaining an objective understanding of areas such as current and historical sales, previous marketing strategies, customer service, business process, organizational culture, management philosophy, industry competition, stakeholder insights, technology, succession planning and more. Most businesses operate in a kind of “bubble”. Inside this bubble they can’t really understand how they are viewed or influenced. Frankly, who is going to tell them the truth? So, in the absence of real quantifiable feedback they often resort to simpler “data” metrics such as sales, margins and personal performance that offer only a part of the overall picture.   

Let’s take a moment to explore a case study to understand how the strategy is applied. You have a company that is successfully producing a product or service. You appear to be doing well. It may be the result of a relatively new product that is in demand; and you are getting many new customers so sales and margins are good. You may have periodic meeting with senior staff to review progress through some standard metrics you have established, such as sales, profit, cost of production, etc. By using this methodology of examining the performance and productivity of your organization you fail to understand some influencing factors that may not immediately show in your metrics.


An objective viewpoint may reveal product development pipeline issues, increased marketplace competition, introduction of new technology, changes in customer demands, unsatisfied vendor relationships and reduced employee motivation. All of these may not readily be apparent in your current metrics and your management team may not be forthcoming when they observe these influencing factors at play, particularly when they are viewed in isolation of each other.


 By thinking long term about the business conduit and establishing a periodic review of the process, from an objective point of view that is outside of your normal reporting and metrics review, you can identify and address these issues before they become significant growth impediments.

Saturday, March 28, 2015

The Marketing Assessment: Measuring Business Performance

Measuring progress on the consistent implementation of marketing and communication strategies is important to the life of any organization or business. Many make the mistake of allowing sales and/or revenue streams to crest and trough, coinciding with changing market forces. Allowing your revue streams to gradually ebb as a result of inactivity or inattentiveness can harm your business dramatically. It can create a scenario where you are ill prepared to take on unforeseen sudden changes in the marketplace, or it can make you unable to effectively fund growth and marketing opportunities properly during a trough in sales.

Most companies or organizations (note I am making a distinction between not for profit “organizations” and for profit “businesses”) take a hap hazard approach to marketing.  They often utilize, what I call the “shinny object” syndrome by marketing based on, whatever initiative catches their attention and falls within generally accepted marketing principles. They tend to support sponsorships, traditional media, inconsistent online strategies, direct mail, events and on occasion some limited public relations.  The problem with all this is, it is generally not well co-ordinated, defined and consistently applied. No one has actually crafted a marketing message that responds to current audience needs and demands; and the results are usually viewed on an individual project-by-project basis with little means of evaluating performance as a group or over time.

The problem is compounded by the fact that most managers, directors, owners, presidents and CEOs all believe they know more than just a little about marketing.  They know their product or service inside out and they understand their business proposition, so they feel qualified to be able to make marketing decisions for their organization or business. In turn, these decision makers empower middle managers, graphic artists, social network specialists and web programmers, often without supporting customer data and product analysis, to institute marketing initiatives.

While all these and many other marketing, advertising, sales and public relations functions can contribute to a marketing program. They can only be successful when implemented under a carefully thought out marketing strategy that has incorporated the tools and means of evaluating performance. That strategy overlays the products and services, features and benefits, customer service strategy, unique selling features and nature of an organization over customer demographics to establish goals and objectives that can be measured or modified as the performance dictates.

The reason that companies and organizations do not enter into such a process readily, is that - more than cost, the process demands the attention of the senior management team. It demands that they participate in a very focused process; evaluating their performance in detail. In a senior decision maker’s world, this is their most valuable resource, time and effort. Diverting management’s attention to conduct a marketing review and put in place a process for evaluating the organization’s performance doesn't seem to measure up to more perceived important company issues, such as new products, ongoing products and services, sales, customer service, etc.


There are marketing strategies that can be employed to help protect companies from troughs in the business cycle or to help grow your organization to the next level. How you answer the questions in our marketing survey will help you understand how prepared your company or organization is.

Thursday, March 12, 2015

Learning From Failure

One of the most underrated strategies for changing the prospects on a product, company, organization or process, is learning from failure and applying what you have learned. Most organizations, and of course the people in them, believe that failure is bad. They also believe that learning from it is pretty straightforward: Ask people to reflect on what they did wrong, perhaps write a report about it and encourage them to avoid similar mistakes in the future. Failure is not always bad. In organizations and companies sometimes failure can be bad, but sometimes it’s inevitable, and sometimes even good. Second, learning from organizational failures is anything but straightforward since most lessons are superficial and they allow us to cling to existing ideas of success.
Failure and fault are virtually inseparable in most organizations. We all learn early that admitting failure means taking the blame. That is why so few organizations reward learning from failure. Failure can come from many sources ranging from inattention, willfully violating a process, lack of ability and process complexity, to uncertainty and exploratory testing. As we go through this range we begin to see that some of these may make it difficult to identify the exact nature of the failure. A sophisticated understanding of failure’s causes and contexts will help institute an effective strategy for learning from failure. Although an infinite number of things can go wrong in organizations, mistakes fall into three broad categories: preventable, complexity-related and intelligent.
Preventable failures in predictable operations: Most failures in this category can indeed be considered “bad.” They usually involve deviations from spec in the closely defined processes of high-volume or routine operations in manufacturing and services. With proper training and support, employees can follow those processes consistently.
Unavoidable failures in complex systems: A large number of organizational failures are due to the inherent uncertainty of work. Although serious failures can be averted by following best practices small process failures are inevitable. To consider them bad is not just a misunderstanding of how complex systems work; it is counterproductive. Avoiding consequential failures means rapidly identifying and correcting small failures.
Intelligent failures at the frontier: Failures in this category can rightly be considered “good,” because they provide valuable new knowledge that can help an organization leap ahead of the competition and ensure its future growth. But failure is still inherently emotionally charged; getting an organization to accept it takes leadership. Insist that your organization develop a clear understanding of what happened, not of “who did it, when things go wrong.
Here are some tips to consistently help learn from failures:
  • Frame the work accurately
  • Embrace messengers
  • Acknowledge limits, invite participation
  • Set boundaries and hold people accountable.