Showing posts with label elearning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label elearning. Show all posts

Thursday, October 11, 2018

ELearning: The “Testing Effect”




“2010 New York Times article reported on a scientific Study
that showed that students who read a passage of text and then
 took a test asking them to recall what they had read retained
 an astonishing 50% more of the information a week later than
 students who had not been tested.”
The “Testing Effect” describes the power of retrieval. Its most common application can be seen in testing in school exams; to help measure learning and assign grades. In the corporate world, this process is often shunned as a facile means of overcoming employee resistance or circumventing policy & procedure issues.

Testing as a whole has come under fire in recent years. Various elementary, secondary and post-secondary learners and academic bodies have cited that testing in the traditional manor is not an effective means of determining comprehension and this notion has carried over into corporate learning to some extent. Testing has gotten a “bad rap” and it is often related to memorization.  

In their book “Make It Stick”, authors Peter C. Brown, Henry L Roediger III and Mark A. McDaniel cited that a “2010 New York Times article reported on a scientific Study that showed that students who read a passage of text and then took a test asking them to recall what they had read retained an astonishing 50% more of the information a week later than students who had not been tested.”

 The book, Make It Stick,  suggests that the New York Times article would seem like good news, but here’s how it was greeted in many online comments:

“Once again, another author confuses learning with recalling information.”

“I personally would like to avoid as many tests as possible, especially with my grades on the line,. Trying to learn in a stressful environment is no way to help retain information.”

“Nobody should care whether memorization is enhanced by practice testing or not. Our children cannot do much of anything anymore.” 

  eLearning can be an important component of learning new skills, enhancing product knowledge, reinforcing policies and procedures or changing behaviour, but only when a well-defined testing process is associated with any given topic or group of topics.  This process enhances retrieval of information and can have an important influence on work practices; but only when content is coupled with a well thought out testing process that is extended over time. 

I suppose the next question is how? How does the process of retrieval of information enhance memory?  The basic concept is this - the act of retrieving information from memory makes it easier to retrieve later. We retrieve information from memory every moment of every day; how to tie a knot, how to start your car, how to program your remote (well maybe not this one), how to add and subtract, etc. These may seem common and mundane but they are made thus through the repetition of retrieving information repeatedly, thereby embedding knowledge more permanently.

I think many of us can bare witness to the effects of retrieval strength in our daily lives, for example, if we go away for an extended trip, our minds would be far away from the normal processes and routines we follow daily. As a result, when we return, we have lost some information, perhaps:  passwords, log in procedures, actions that we may undertake less frequently but typically would recall when retrieved periodically. This can be described as the ebbing of retrieval strength. We are not reminded of the information and gradually we forget.

What does it all mean for eLearning? I think we have to re-consider how we perceive testing, its frequency and the veracity of the testing process. In designing learning programs within corporate environments, we often view learning as a one-time event or a one-time window. We tend to design testing around that event or window but do not plan repeated opportunities to review content, refresh knowledge and enhance retrieval strength through a more rigorous testing process over the long term.

The process need not be onerous. We recommend offering shorter and more persistent testing on information. Make sure the information is prioritized, meaning focus on topics of greater importance to your organization’s mission. For example you may evaluate your learning calendar for a given year and consider reintroduction of key learning principles along with repeated testing opportunities. This can be coupled with the introduction of new content each calendar year. 

Making the process fun and “not boring” will have an important effect on learning and embedding information making it easier to retrieve, however and perhaps more importantly, designing an ongoing process of presenting the prioritized information through multiple channels while reinforcing the learning process with testing is essential to effecting change through learning in your organization.

Friday, April 20, 2018

Learning: Not A One-Time Event

The upshot of all this is that spaced out intervals of 
study reinforces learning and learned practices.

Learning in general, and eLearning in particular are largely regarded as a onetime events in most organizational settings today. The ever increasing pace of change, the avalanche of information, the increased activity within any given job responsibility have created a need to develop an ever-green strategy for learning within an organization.

The evergreen approach to learning should result in a lifelong process of learning within an organization that periodically reinforces existing information, along with new concepts and skills that relate to a particular topic. Yes…it does demand additional resources and funding to dedicate learning as a core concept within an organization. This has not been particularly high on the list of budget items for most organizations. 

Why do I make a case for an evergreen approach? - well because through my experience in developing eLearning for various organizations over the past 25 years I have found that most if not all organizations I have worked with have tended to look at developing learning and eLearning on a project by project basis? While costs have not increased dramatically, the pace of change, the scope of content has – which leaves me wondering why new and more strategic approach to learning have not been implemented.

Common sense tells us we are not doing a very good at creating effective learning environments. When I refer to this I am referring to learning outside the traditional school system. Research tells us that spaced learning produces superior test scores. The question becomes for developing any learning strategy, “What is the typical interval of spaced learning that produces good storage and retrieval strength” (see my article on How We Learn). There is no real handbook or definitive data on this but there is some research that provides a pretty reliable guide to how we can space eLearning and learning in general to improve retention, comprehension and application.

In 2008, a research team led by Melony Wiseheart a psychologist at York University, Toronto and Harold Pashler, a psychologist at the University of California, San Diego, conducted a large study that provided the first good answer to this question. The book “How We Learn” explains that the team enrolled 1354 people from all ages from across the US. The team had them study 32 obscure facts. The participants studied the facts at different intervals –some only 10 minutes apart and others as much as 6 months apart. In total there were 26 different study intervals. The researchers also varied the timing of the final exam.

The study produced an optimal interval chart to help us better understand the relationship between spaced learning and remembering what you have learned.  

Time To Test
First Study Interval
        Week
1-2 days
1 Month
1 week
3 Months
2 weeks
6 Months
3 weeks
1 Year
1 month

The further away the exam the more the time you have to prepare - the larger the optimal between sessions one and two. This study included a test to validate the learning process. In most organizational learning (as opposed to traditional school learning) and even eLearning where testing is relatively easy, testing is not always a part of the process.

The upshot of all this is that spaced out intervals of study reinforces learning and learned practices in eLearning. ELearning is usually implemented as a one off and there is rarely follow up through eLearning or other learning methods. This results in poor adoption of learned skills or practices.

In a well-designed “evergreen learning approach” the reintroduction of concepts will help under-write a spaced out study process creating a continuum of learning. This will result in the better application of learned skills and processes, while exposing the learner to new information. In a planned approach to learning this might include spaced out eLearning programs where existing concepts are reexamined and new or revised content is added to create depth of knowledge. Testing is also an important part of the process to ensure that learners take the process as seriously as those who have planned out the learning program.

Finally, based on the previous article “How We Learn” - using different delivery methods of knowledge will help improve “storage and retrieval strength.” For example you may utilize eLearning as a core component, offering  versions of the same eLearning modules with new questions, which can then reinforce with scheduled events, webinars, activities, and print based elements throughout a one year learning cycle. Often, these are not costly; they just demand planning an evergreen approach to learning.


Tuesday, March 6, 2018

How We Learn: Storage & Retrieval Strength

" Learning is rooted very much in the mind’s ability  to 

extrapolate a broad range information linked to external stimulus..."

A common thread that affects learning and our comprehension is “How We Learn”. Funny, isn’t it - that this is perhaps the single most important factor in developing learning programs –yet it is the least understood and often least considered aspect of skill development and behavioural change.

 Learning programs, and in particular eLearning programs demand that an individual focus on a set of learning objectives we have set out for that learner. We seek to entrench comprehension and change behaviour through such learning programs. Most learning strategies within organizations and corporations are based on cost and availability of resources with little concern for long term implementation strategies and a need to validate learning.  Effective eLearning involves understanding how our brain works to store, recall and apply knowledge. If we don’t understand how that takes place and how we can best create an environment that will allow this to happen, how can we hope people will apply what they have learned.

Traditional classrooms and their learning strategies are built on historical experiences in organized learning regimens and do not create a connection between learning and understanding. The foundational learning strategies we currently use in most of our business learning environments date back to the 19th century. Experiential learning or the classroom based learning in a one to many environment is the primary means of teaching/learning.
This strategy is entrenched in teachers and learners who focus on a learning formula that suggests: creating a link between memorization, repetition and application equals comprehension and learned skills. It is my contention, based on the existing data sets resulting from many learning studies, that there is significant evidence that this is not the most effective way to teach or learn, however, it may be the cheapest. I wonder of cheaper is better if nothing is learned?

Learning is rooted very much in the mind’s ability to extrapolate a broad range information linked to external stimulus, thus creating links in our ability to store, recall and apply knowledge based on how that knowledge gets embedded.  Creating unique environments, delivering a message in a memorable way and allowing the learner to learn in a way that suites their abilities and capacity to paramount to learning. Check out the Godden & Baddeley study on the effects of context cues on recall.

Robert Bjork of UCLA and his wife, Elizabeth Ligon Bjork also of UCLA can be said to have developed the theory of “Forget To Learn” in the 80’s. The principle theory is this “Any memory has two strengths, a storage strength and a retrieval strength.”  

“How We Learn”, author, Benedict Carey, tells us that storage strength is just that, a measure of how well learned something is. It builds up steadily with studying and more sharply with use.”   He goes on to say, “According to Bjorks theory, storage strength can increase but never decrease”…and, “The brain holds onto only what is relevant, useful or interesting - or maybe so in the future.”   Casey tells us that “Retrieval strength…is a measure of how easily a nugget of information comes to mind. It too, increases with studying and with use.”
Retrieval strength can be a matter of how quickly we can bring things to mind, while storage strength is a matter of how familiar something might be. ELearning is affected by this learning philosophy. If an eLearning program, for example has 6 modules, and each is about 45 minutes long which we take only once, than the storage strength and retrieval strength are both low.

How do we improve on this? Each module can be followed up with questions. This serves as repetition of content and improves retrieval. Adding case studies and interactive scenarios helps improve storage strength as we apply and use the knowledge. We can further improve storage and retrieval with follow up meetings and one-on-one sessions that extend our learning of the concept, by creating a series of demands on our memory that recall and apply the principles learned.

Spreading out the learning process over a longer period of time, changing the delivery medium and varying the time and place in which we learn are all hall marks of eLearning. This creates an environment where the knowledge can become more embedded in our memory, improving our storage and retrieval strength and allowing us to recall information more readily. This is especially true if we continue to follow up and extend the learning process through a variety of additional learning opportunities. These complementary learning opportunities that complement eLearning can be simple and low cost including; group meetings, one-on-one simulations, learner surveys, reading assignments, learner feedback, follow up evaluation of implementation strategies, etc.  

ELearning is an ideal medium for knowledge transfer, but on its own it’s is far less effective. Learning strategies, that use eLearning as the primary learning medium, delivered over longer periods while including multiple learning opportunities and multiple mediums create the best outcomes.

Monday, February 6, 2017

Building an eLearning Strategy

Develop strategies that deal
with contractors, unionized
workers and salaried staff.
Over the past several years, eLearning has gradually been integrated into the knowledge transfer process of industry and government.  Unfortunately, the creation of most eLearning is usually based on a mix of existing internal programs originally developed as print, web and video; or they simply buy an available eLearning program from the open marketplace. Organizations simply take an existing program and, more often than not with some minor alterations, upload the content to an Learning Management System (LMS) with short term planning goals and budgetary restraints. In many cases they spend more time and money on selecting an LMS than they do on the actual content. Understanding how to build responsive and effective content is important when you consider asking employees to do some if not most of their training on personal time.

Additional resources, pre-testing, test quizzes; access to mentoring, cohort knowledge sharing, program feedback and a commitment to link outcomes to performance are all issues that typically are not addressed. These eLearning considerations and learning program strategies affect the learner’s ability to change behaviors or to incorporate knowledge into their practices and planning processes.

To be fair, budgets, union bargaining, lack of long term strategies, lack of experience and unsupported eLearning implementation provide some context for explaining why organizations simply choose the path of least resistance. For example an organization might upload PDFs with text and images; or existing PowerPoint presentations; or even use an interactive web site. There are many solutions out there that can meet "budgeted" learning demands of an organization but getting results requires more serious planning before eLearning content gets produced and implemented, even when content already exists. Don’t get me wrong, content that exists is important and a valuable asset that can be leveraged to reduce overall development costs and support comprehension.

The best way to address these and other considerations in eLearning planning and implementation is to develop a two pronged strategy before you ever consider content. First develop a long term plan (3 years) that seeks to integrate unionized employees (where applicable), contractors, regular hourly employees and salaried staff into the eLearning program incrementally.  Three years to integrate unionized staff is ambitious, when you consider the need to address concerns by their bargaining unit. And second, create incentives in the program to reward performance. This can be measured through peer review and annual performance reviews that track and document the comprehension and application of knowledge in day to day tasks.   These two considerations are challenging to implement, because they require all levels of management and employees or even contractors to be invested in the process.  

Once you have that plan documented and supported, next comes the production of content that is linked to comprehension and changes in behavior. Laying the planning foundation ensures you have the tools to more effectively implement eLearning within your organization.  Without it, we are simply spending a lot of money to provide yet another way for learners to forget or ignore what they have learned.

Thursday, March 17, 2016

eLearning: SME’s & the Creative Process


Classroom training adds reoccurring commitment
of  time, effort & cost
Instructional design and creative direction are essential to the creation of intuitive eLearning; they help empower the learner to explore content and they create a desire to engage. This becomes a difficult process when most interactive content and Subject Matter Experts are born in the crucible of the ivory tower learning paradigm. The Subject Matter Expert (SME), or teacher and the creative development team represent two very different sensibilities when trying to create an intuitive learning environment.

For the SME, each topic is carefully detailed, researched and written down in a formalized text of some sort that can be agreed on and finalized, often by a peer committee review process. At least that’s the typical classroom style learning process we have grown up with. 

But this is changing as we go from classroom to virtually any place to learn online, without a teacher or instructor to guide us. Regardless of the source of the content the resulting “knowledge guide” used to develop eLearning is enshrined at some point in a traditional written form such as textbooks, subject matter expert content briefs, studies, instructions, guidelines and regulations. The content is often very specific, structured and unwavering in identifying the basic tenants of any topic to ensure that there is an agreed upon knowledge base.
The ability to deliver this carefully defined information in a meaningful way has largely depended on the environment and the person delivering the information. The “classroom teacher” often chooses what to accentuate, when to emphasize certain content and how to best illustrate key elements of content to reinforce comprehension of the basic principles of a concept. With the advent of eLearning, both the environment and the teacher involved in delivery of learning have been changed, embedded or even eliminated for the most part. As learning delivery methods have moved to an online environment, so too has the medium moved to a different kind of learning development process.  

The question now becomes who or what has replaced the “on the ground” teacher’s role in this new method of learning? How is the textbook knowledge being delineated in online learning and how are we guiding the learner? The surprising answer to these questions is that much of the responsibility for interpreting content through the interactive process has fallen to the eLearning instructional designer and the creative director. They now fulfill the role of interpreting the information to create a learning environment that allows for intuitive comprehension. The overall benefit in this change is that, no longer is the learner at mercy of the teacher’s choices. The learner now has an expanded role in interacting with the content to choose to explore knowledge that reflects individual interest within a topic.

In many ways this is a much more dynamic learning environment where learners can begin to explore the content in meaningful ways while still absorbing the basic principle designed into the learning programs content. The unfortunate pitfall in all of this, just as in the teacher enabled learning environment, the effectiveness of an online learning program is largely based on the skill of the interpreter, and in this case it is the interactive development team. Understanding adult learning, digital media production and interactive design are crucial if the Self-Paced eLearning or Blended learning is going to be successful.

In the eLearning development cycle, unlike within classroom learning, the development pipeline from concept to delivery is much shorter and the subject matter expert can exert much more influence on the content, or so it would seem. However, in reality the typical subject matter expert has only the knowledge of the 2D representation of the information, i.e., books, documentation, practical application etc., while online learning is now representing the content in a more 3D format which cannot be effectively managed and directed by the subject matter expert. They must rely on the skill and ability of the design team to creatively interpret the information in an interactive form that engages and creates comprehension. The more a subject matter expert tries to impose structure on the content the less intuitive, creative and engaging the content becomes, ultimately subordinating comprehension to structure and minimizing the learner’s ability to control the learning experience.

In thinking about this you may have noticed this process is not dissimilar to the video production cycle where there are many influencing factors and unknowns in the development process even though we have a clear understanding of what final product we would like to arrive at. Ultimately the production team including the instructional designer, writer, creative director, etc. must be trusted to influence the final production and achieve the aforementioned goals of the learning experience. Not surprisingly, like film and televisions production, subject matter experts can have a significant and positive influence on an eLearning production but not without great cost, time and effort.

In short if you want a great eLearning production and you want to manage time and cost effectively, you need to recognize your role in that process and make sure you have a great creative team that understands digital media production (often this kind of talent comes out of the television industry), adult learning and interactive design. A successful eLearning experience is less about a specific process that can be carefully managed, but more about an intuitive process that generates a creative understanding of the content that gives the learner the power to explore and the desire to engage.

Tuesday, December 15, 2015

elearning Wrong Thinking


Our company has been developing e Learning since the 90's, before it was ever thought to be "cool" or "effective" in training. During that time we have encountered many implementation strategies that bear close examination for their ineffectiveness and their inability to actually achieve any true measure of comprehension among learners. 

Most e Learning administrators ignored or overlooked the important lessons taught by traditional learning. For example, you must have an administrative infrastructure in place with allocated resources, its OK to expect results from learners, its OK to set high achievement levels in testing, and adult learning is a shared enterprise that includes learners, teachers and administrators. 

Here are a few e Learning thought processes that can potentially result in poor comprehension and boredom among learners.
,  
  1. Our first priority is to try and buy the most seats for the lowest price
  2.  Let’s focus on purchasing an LMS solution before we consider content 
  3.  We’ll try and use content we already have. PowerPoint is better than nothing.
  4.  Let’s be cost effective and buy off-the-shelf-content without evaluating its effectiveness
  5.  Don’t bother involving learners in e Learning program design....that’s too complicated
  6.  Isn’t self-paced e Learning fully automated? … no need to develop a management plan
  7.  Do not make completion of the e Learning mandatory – people might complain
  8.  Don’t set up a program to promote the idea of e Learning – it’s too much work and money
  9.  Don’t include a firm completion date – I am sure it will be get done in due course
  10.  I am managing the e Learning program,….I don’t have to actually take it myself
  11.  Don’t track and include e Learning results in employee records – it’s too hard to put in place
  12.  Training is important but it’s not core to our business or organization 
  13.  Let's start our e Learning program with low cost mandatory learning 
  14.  I’ll make the e Learning optional – that way it won’t be difficult to implement
  15.  We already do workshops and conferences…e Learning isn’t that different 
  16.  Let’s implement self-paced e Learning...and then we can set it up in a classroom
  17.  We want a certificate e Learning program …but we should make it easy to get
  18.  We can implement an e Learning program …no need to plan for any updates at this point
  19.  Let’s create an e Learning program…I’m sure learners will participate without reward or encouragement 
  20. Content is expensive ...let's see of somebody else has the custom knowledge we need
PS....fell free to respond with your own observations on e Learning implementation ....

Tuesday, December 8, 2015

eLearning;Making The Grade?

As learning has spread beyond the classroom through new technologies into organizations, businesses and associations, each has had to take on the responsibility of creating their own unique learning environment and administrative implementation model. Self-paced eLearning, blended eLearning and online learning have created a demand within these organizations to commit resources to develop an learning strategy that incorporates program levels & descriptions, performance monitoring, content development, audience surveys, testing, tracking & reporting, promotions and budgeting.
 Unfortunately, these demands have resulted in a very uneven and fragmented implementation process that has not benefited the organization or its employees. Here are a few examples of some of the incomplete and ineffective learning strategies that I have encountered in the marketplace, as organizations and companies try and implement a learning strategy.  
 The Layered Approach: learning approaches are layered one on top of the other. The organization uses workshops, conferences, webinars, eLearning and teleconferences without assessing the effectiveness of each medium. No overarching strategic Learning plan has been developed that links effectiveness, audience demands, learning objectives to results and budgets.
 One-Off Solution: when an organization looks at an individual learning initiative in isolation and develops a onetime solution that addresses the issue in the short term. This can lead to a layered approach that creates higher costs and ineffective application of learning and/or poorly understood learning outcomes within companies.  You can utilize multiple learning delivery mechanisms including eLearning and workshops if they are vetted through an overarching Learning strategy and budget rationalization process.
 Off -The-Shelf Solution: this occurs when an organization lacks capacity to implement learning through its own resources yet has developed a learning strategy at a senior management level. This top down approach may not consider both short term and long term impact. Short term financial gains may blind a company to the demands of administrative oversight in the learning process - so the company hires a contractor to fulfill short term demands.   
 The Technology Approach: when an organization seeks to fulfill its learning mandate by implementing some form of technology without a clear long term plan to utilize it effectively. An example might be an organization purchasing a Learning Management System (LMS) without content, or without a clear understanding of audience demands and or the need to allocate long term resources to administering the organizational learning process.  
 The Do Nothing Plan: “if it works don’t fix it”, a common axiom that doesn’t ring true in this circumstance. Many organizations ignore the need for a learning strategy and simply opt to use the mediums and strategies that have been in place historically. They may lack the resources to deliver learning more efficiently through such mediums as eLearning and as a result they become less competitive and have greater employee turnover.
The reason for many of these fragmented and ineffective implementation strategies is that most organizations do not have the in-house knowledge and experience necessary to undertake a thorough learning review. A company does not commit the resources  to help understand how they can create learning environments that make use of best practice across a variety of learning mediums to improve performance and capacity …and all within budget. They often rely on a mixed bag of external resources to guide them and when the process is complete the organization has not internalized the knowledge necessary to effectively implement a learning program that gets results.  
 When this organizational knowledge transfer does not take place there is no consistent administrative body or champion within most organizations that has the capacity to enforce learning objectives, make a case for learning and learning budgets and ensure that the learning has an impact on the effectiveness of both the employees and the organization. Most administrators are simply overwhelmed or simply unprepared to implement online learning and lack the tools and support to undertake the initiative.
 In the final summation, what is the purpose of training, if not to improve both personal and organization performance and capacity?

Monday, June 22, 2015

eLearning Towards Organizational Success

Champion creative risk taking and engage learners 
and link performance to organizational and individual success.
Our company has been involved in developing eLearning since 2004, when we developed our first full-featured eLearning module. Since then, adoption of eLearning has been slow as companies and organizations have continued to invest in less efficient traditional classroom-style or lecture style training, with predictably poor results. Recently, we have witnessed an increase in the adoption rate of eLearning as a primary tool in training and development; but often the planning and implementation are tactical, and little consideration is given to the most important aspect of learning, comprehension. We thought we would take a moment out to share our insights into eLearning implementation pitfalls.  
  • Over the past several years we have observed many RFPs from companies and organizations and in almost every circumstance, the RFP were often primarily designed around the purchase of a Learning Management System (LMS).  Content and comprehension are generally viewed as an afterthought.
  •  eLearning content, as we have witnessed in many programs across Canada are often a patchwork of legacy content. Programs often include legacy web based content, video snippets, documents, PDFs and PowerPoint. In the rare circumstances where organizations are producing content they often do not have the expertise to product content for today's media savvy sophisticated professional worker.
  • Most organizations do not enforce a vibrant testing and reporting eLearning process.  In some circumstances this may be a result of mixed union and non-union environments, in others it’s a lack of commitment to developing a comprehensive learning strategy and in still other circumstances it is the result of not including learners in the learning strategy development process.
  • Many compulsory or compliance eLearning courses are simple and lack any creativity, and most skilled workers try and skip the content and go directly to the questions to get through the process with as little focus as possible. Most will cheat on the test portion given the chance, since there is little in the content to challenge them and programs often lack incentive to achieve and opportunities to share knowledge are virtually non-existent.
  • eLearning technology, while generally sophisticated from an administration and reporting point of view are rarely utilized to their full extent to understand the learner experience. Administrators stick to the same basic reporting criteria, pass/fail, completion score, name and department. Often learning programs are under-resourced and performance in learning programs is not tied directly to organizational and individual success.  
  • Many eLearning programs fail to incorporate the learner in the process. The system often does not include gathering consistent learner feedback on the experience in terms of their engagement or their ability to share knowledge among peers, as is the case in traditional learning environments. This is often a result of designing eLearning as an adjunct to existing training programs. They are thought of as a cost cutting measure rather than a new form of learning that is persistent.
  • Leaders in management groups, teams and committees often see and understand the value of eLearning and create mandates for implementation but implementation becomes a logistical or tactical implementation plan rather than a larger strategy linked to performance. Cost reduction becomes the number one driving factor in eLearning design and implementation rather than comprehension and organizational success.
  • Most organizations take a very traditional approach to a learning process by not championing creative "risk-taking" in the design and implementation of eLearning programs.  Little in the way of testing unique programs, lateral learning opportunities, or innovation is occurring in eLearning, primarily due to cost.  Creating management teams that consider efficacy as well as creativity, can have a profound effect on individual performance and organizational success.
  • Failure is an important part of learning. In most eLearning curricula and modules, the possibility of failure is either absent or minimized. Creating learning from failure can be realized  by creating higher threshold achievement levels, more complex information, more difficult questions, random test questions or checkpoint questions that allows the learner to gauge their understanding. Do not be afraid to challenge the learner but create additional incentives to succeed as well.
These thoughts and observations are designed to challenge thinking on current eLearning strategies. Just implementing eLearning is not enough …organizations and businesses need to implement learning strategies that are tied to individual and organizational performance results.

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Sacrificing Comprehension On The Altar of Ephemera?

The average attention span in 2001 was 12 seconds; in 2013 it
was 8  seconds; a goldfish’s attention span is 9 seconds.
So often we come across abbreviated lists of behaviours that are designed to “shortcut” the process of learning. We understand that learning is a process of transformation that demands we apply time and effort to modify behaviours, thoughts and actions. Why then do we deliver learning in facile lists distilled down to the simplest steps or in classrooms and workshops?

 Are we sacrificing comprehension on the altar of ephemera or are we boring a new generation tasked with learning to adopt to a technology based culture?  Do we truly understand the nature of learning as a society or have we been duped by a culture steeped in the glorification of youth and its ability to adapt to technology.   

We appear to be moving from a culture of thoughtful attention to one of distracted focus. For example, in the sixties, movies scenes held a viewer’s attention of about 20 seconds, today that has shrunk to about 2 – 3 seconds. The average attention span in 2001 was 12 seconds; in 2013 it was 8 seconds; a goldfish’s attention span is 9 seconds. Today 51% of millennials prefer video to text.  In 2013 adults aged 50 to 64 upped their consumption of online video from 11 minutes a day to 19 minutes a day. This year it is predicted we will consume more than 15 hours a day of media.

I believe that there is a sweet spot in the learning process that responds to shorter attention spans while providing the information in a way; at a time, and in in a format that is easily consumed by a more media savvy younger generation of learners.

As developers and designers of learning programs particularly in the areas of eLearning and blended learning we are constantly faced with the challenge of addressing shortened attention spans and alternative learning scenarios as dictated by the largest group of learners, young people (which we would identify as 18 – 34). Although the case for shortened attention spans would dictate a change in learning strategies training decision makers, in their wisdom, continue to rely primarily on a traditional “bums in seats” strategy for learning.

Consider this; in the US business spend over 160 billion is spent annually on training, 80% is forgotten in 30 days and 90% within one year. The average time to create 1 hour of classroom learning is estimated at between 43 and 185 hours. The average time an employee trains in a year is 30 hours and fewer than 15% apply what they have learned.   The 90/20/8 rule tells us that in the first 8 minutes of learning we are at our peek energy level, after 20 minute our neurons experience a noticeable drop in activity and after 60 to 120 minutes our alertness completely collapses.

 While short lists, tips, guidelines and tricks provide some easily digestible information, we almost always treat this information as disposable. It offers no means of truly comprehending the ideas and offers little in terms of depth of knowledge. On the other end of the spectrum, traditional learning doesn’t work either. We believe that shorter intervals of eLearning respond to the need for multiple streams of information, a preference for high stimulation and lower tolerance for boredom.

References: Hayles, University of California; USC Marshall School of Business, ScienceDaily; Levels Beyond, Direct Marketing News; National Center for Biotechnology Information, The Associated
Press; Cross-Platform Report, Nielsen Q2 2104; Harris Survey, Grovo 2014; Human Capital Trends Switzerland 2014, Deloitte; National Sleep Foundation, BusinessWeek; American
Dietetic Association; McKinsey, BusinessWeek; Skills Soft; The Association forTalent Development; Via Learning Solutions; Wall Street Journal; Pike, Creative Training;
Techniques Handbook; Goldstein, Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research, and Everyday Experience; Bailey, Mindgym; Jimenez, “3 minute learning”; eLearning Infographics, Mobile Learning Generation

Monday, October 20, 2014

Blended Learning Strategy– Cost Effective Training

If you've not satisfied with continual staff turnover, escalating salary bidding wars and the quality of your current workforce skills you may want to consider a Blended Learning Strategy for your company. With the advent of eLearning, a cost-effective blended learning strategy for a small business employers can now be developed to train a workforce for both soft skills and practical skills. The formula might include a syllabus of off-the-shelf eLearning for soft skills, on-the-job training for practical skills, a process for filtering likely successful candidates, a means of testing milestone comprehension and a good benefits package to attract and retain the best possible candidates. 

It is an investment, for sure, but it can be very cost effective when you measure this against all the time and effort you dedicate to managing your workforce, the quality of work preformed, the cost of developing leadership and communications skills, the cost of retaining good performers and the effect that "churn" has on productivity, Developing a focused Blended Learning strategy pays long term dividends for businesses and organizations that are focused on growth. The changing economy and the rise of the too-skilled worker demographic has led to an unusual segmentation in the available labour force. This is borne out by the many discussions I have had with small to medium size employers who experience on ongoing shortage of talent. Many companies we work with could actually grow more rapidly if they could count on a skilled workforce to meet their demands.  

Pundits and experts point to the lack of training investment, economic uncertainty, poorly designed government programs and lack of employer vision in developing training programs - as the main culprits in this seeming shortage of qualified labour. Hard to lament a shortage in labour when the economy as a whole continues to sputter and unemployment continues to be an issue.

I believe, however, the employment shortage is real and not just imagined. In recognizing this shortage - I have identified three distinct groups of unemployed which can help us create solutions. The first group is the over –qualified university “Educated Worker” with eyes on a middle management position and little or no experience, the second is the “Employed” that has the skills and are actively being pursued by competing companies, while the third group, in this over simplified model, is the unemployed who may have little or no post-secondary education, not a lot of experience and are seeking opportunities with a future in a marketplace filled with service industry and part time positions.

A recent Labour Market Partnership (LMP) study (over 2,000 small businesses participated ) identified the following 10 learning requirements for small businesses, including: people skills/relationship-building, communication skills, problem solving skills, analytical abilities, leadership skills, industry-specific knowledge & experience, functional knowledge, technological literacy, project management skills and creative thinking.  

Accessing available online training for the bulk of the skills required and implementing a structured on-the job-training program can address the need for skilled labour in an organized and cost effective way. Adding a means of filtering recruits, testing for milestone comprehension and developing a strategy for ensuring they stay with the organization over the long term can make this training initiative a very cost effective means of acquiring and retaining a skilled workforce.

In today’s workplace it’s no longer good enough for employers, particularly in the manufacturing and industrial marketplace, to simply hope that there is a qualified talent pool, outbid competing companies or count on government initiatives that will address the need for unique skill sets. Employers need to invest in their own training program that leverages available low cost learning solutions for soft skills coupled with an on-the-job training program for practical skills. The magic additional ingredients in such a program are: the ability to benchmark test applicants, filter and select only the best potential applicants and develop a strategy for retaining these skills with a strong company vision and a good benefits package. Contact us to learn more.


Wednesday, September 10, 2014

MOOCs & Corporate Training?

MOOCs have the capacity to
change the way we look at eLearning
Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) are beginning to make a splash in the corporate training world as organizations begin to adopt this technology for internal training and customer service and customer relationship building.  For those who may not be familiar with the term a MOOC is “massive “in that it allows thousands of learners to participate at any one time in a course or program, “open,” because anyone with an Internet connection can enroll in a course; and they are “courses” because they have a start and end date, learner testing and benchmark achievement levels and /or proctored exams.

The term free and verification are often used when describing MOOCs but again this is a misnomer. As with anything in the real world, you rarely get anything for free (courses often cost between $30 - $100) and few of the courses offer verification …especially the free ones. Forbes magazine suggests that only about 14% of the courses at one of the largest MOOCs in North America  are verified in some way.   

A MOOC is a concept that incorporates lateral learning and thinking process.  Typically a syllabus is created with the content such as online articles, web links, blogs, wikis, videos, etc., that offer important information on the topic being discovered during a given time frame of the program or course. The learners explore the content and engage in dialogue with other learners and external subject matter experts. Gradually the learning group establishes its own understanding and focuses of the content and can assess their progress against the entire group of learners. Dave Cormier the originator ofthe term MOOC ( no relation that I know of) offers a short and concise explanation.
Now that we have established the idea of a MOOC (which originated from the academic world) we need to gain some insight into how it is implemented at the corporate world. The difference between academic and corporate may seem subtle but nothing could be further from the truth. Academic settings are ideal in that funding for content is already in place and the learning can be extended to an audience outside of the paid program allowing them to learn along with program participants.  In a corporate setting there are three basic learning paths governed by the demands of business, compliance training to which the employer is legally bound, productivity & skills training and customer service learning. In these cases there is no corporate funding so the planning and strategy of a MOOC remains similar to a standard corporate training environment except that the training can be allowed to cross pollinate within the business and the same knowledge and format can be extended to customers outside the business.

While MOOCs are touted as a new and advanced frontier in learning – if there are to be effective they demand planning and lots of it. The “Garbage In…Garbage Out” rule applies here perhaps more than in traditional learning systems simply because of the increasingly sophisticated approach.  Multiple audiences lateral learning, expanded content, social networks all add to the effectiveness of learning and extend learning throughout the organization but they do demand increased strategic planning. Large organizations can employ this approach much more readily because of their already considerable investment in learning, the poor existing track record of learning within organizations and the benefits that can be harvested when they extend product and service learning opportunities to their customers. 

Smaller organizations can benefit from the unique learning opportunities of MOOCs but it is important to carefully consider a strategy and implementation plan that benefits them every step of the way.

Thursday, August 21, 2014

eLearning – Will Tools or Strategy Save Us?

Understanding what is possible leads to success!
A new learning paradigm is sweeping across all sectors of the economy and beginning to affect our lives in many unseen ways.  Two major factors are driving this change - the human factor which fuels our increasing need for knowledge, and the costs associated with delivering that knowledge. Our civilization and indeed our very social fabric have always relied on tools to solve such problems, while strategy has often taken a back seat. 

 Our history is littered with examples of technology that has proven ineffective until careful thought has been applied to their use. One such example comes to mind through the Department of National Defense (Canada) who designed ejection seats for early fighter planes that cut off the legs of the pilot if he was too big. I am sure each of us has been exposed to poor software design when we try and shop or buy something online…somehow the programmer always seems to be the designer of the interaction. All too often the end user is not consulted and the tools we develop fail to meet our needs because they do not consider or consult the end user- in this case “learners.”

 As might be expected, big business has always stepped in to leverage an opportunity; like providing a driver and a bus with no final destination or map to guide us. Learning Management Systems and Learning development tool sets are ubiquitous today …offering us the ability to deliver learning anywhere, anytime at low cost. Organizational administrators are tasked with the increasingly complicated learning demands - struggling to make sense of the technology and how to best meet their needs. Trying to filter through the avalanche of eLearning tools and promotions as many companies rush to meet the needs can be troubling. Little time if any is relegated to the idea of implementing a learning strategy first, before deploying a tool set.

Most organizations take one of two very different routes to achieve their learning goals. The first option is to try and understand needs and demands of learners from legacy learning experiences - and without conducting a thorough assessment of changing learner needs. This often results in re-purposing existing legacy information into useful learning by utilizing new tools sets such as Learning Management Systems, without fully understanding their impact.

The second and much more complex option is the “Strategy First Option” which involves seeking to understand current learner needs and learning organizational goals by conducting a more in-depth assessment. Understanding the nature of learners in your organization may include defining not only organizational learning goals but personal improvement and broader overall knowledge growth. Developing a strategy first option doesn't need to take a great deal of time and effort  but it does take some very specific thought. Laying out a plan that includes organizational learning goals, audience learning preferences, prioritizing topic development and putting into place the administration and promotional resources required to effectively implement a learning strategy over the long term will ensure success.

Once you have a strategy in place you can then begin selecting tools, topics and partners to develop and implement a learning plan that meets your organizational needs… but perhaps more importantly, in developing a strategy you have gained the trust of learners, created a framework for learning and generated awareness of the learning initiative.  

I am happy to share my strategy checklist - let's connect to explore the possible.  

Friday, July 25, 2014

Engaging Your Customers...Narrowcasting is Now

Marketing Budget +/- by Media for 2014
Have a careful look at this chart... while it provides us with a snap shot of the dramatic change in advertising budgets it also underlines the move from Broadcasting to Narrowcasting. The percentages of budgets that are slated to grow in 2014 are largely confined to those media that are narrowly focused on unique audiences, while the large broadcasting budgets are seeing significant declines.

There is a reduced need for broadcasting, as new technologies allow us to reach segmented audiences more effectively and immediately with the depth of information that appeals to customer loyalty.  And …if organizations are going to reach these smaller audience in a meaningful way  they have to offer benefits and advantages that small audience are looking for -  breadth and depth of knowledge and the ability to choose when and how they want to engage. In a nut shell -   this is the difference today between broadcasting and narrowcasting …broadcasting presents one message to a broad audience while narrow casting delivers different messages to individual members of smaller audiences.

Those companies and organizations who can dominate their niche or category are successful when they leverage a consensual relationship with unique incentives and advantages, depth of information and delivery of that information at time and ...in a way ...that appeals to customers. Like all mediums, broadcasting mediums like radio, or television and print before them …will continue to have an audiences for the foreseeable future…it will just be a smaller piece of the pie ....old mediums never die they simply loose the top spot to more responsive media.

Narrow audiences today can be as few as dozens or hundreds, or as broad as hundreds of thousands - but in the light of the public broadcasting spectrum we once held sacrosanct …these audiences seem insignificant. But …if you were to dialogue with organizations who hold these audiences as their core customers, such as an association of members, suppliers to niche business categories, unique business verticals or specific health care audiences or audiences interested in a very specific topics, be it leisure, entertainment, sports or travel we would find out that each specific audience and even each person within that audience has unique demands and interests.

Narrow casting is the reason new technologies evolve and are sought after….each new iteration usually offers more responsive features. E-Learning, responsive web sites, mobile device apps and social networks all contribute to enhance narrowcasting and allowing us to more closely engage with our customers and respond to their needs.  

The standard guidelines for advertising still apply regardless of the channel or medium you work in; as an audience, people are still driven by emotion, personal preferences, lifestyle and by gender & ethnic tendencies. Great creative, consistent messages, using multiple channels and frequency are still the main stays of any well thought out marketing plan aimed at a very small but loyal audience for your product or service. More than ever the evolution of technology is driving the growth behind new advertising mediums and leveling playing field between the large corporate entities and the small to medium size want-to-be businesses.

Those that seek out and engage with new strategies and ways of communicating with their clients have the most to gain in dominating their segment of the market.

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Synchronous or A Synchronous E-Learning?


The question is not really “which” but “how” and perhaps even “when” do we use Synchronous or Asynchronous E-Learning. It’s kind of like the relationship between the “text book” and the “teacher” or the more colloquial “hand and glove.”  But before we can tackle the subject of “which” we need to determine “what” defines Synchronous or Asynchronous E-Learning.

Asynchronous learning is a student-centered teaching method that uses online learning resources to facilitate information sharing outside the constraints of time and place among a network of people. This approach combines self-study with asynchronous interactions to promote learning, and this combined network of learners and the electronic network in which they communicate is referred to as an asynchronous learning network.

Synchronous learning refers to a group of people learning the same things at the same time in the same place. This is the type of pedagogy practiced in most schools which emulate a face-to-face environment and with the advent of web conferencing tools, people can learn at the same time in different places as well. For example, use of instant messaging or live chat, webinars and video conferencing allow for students and teachers to collaborate and learn in real time.

Best practice E-Learning may use one or both Synchronous and Asynchronous learning to generate effective comprehension. Which method works best is defined by the nature of the content and the audience.  

Some content is best suited for Asynchronous E-Learning, where more technical, regulatory or systematic knowledge needs to be imparted and the leaner can learn at their own pace within a preferred environment.  This can often take the form of mandated learning such as workplace regulatory knowledge or compliance related information. Asynchronous E-Learning continues to utilize the broad spectrum of tools such as video, text, images, interactivity and photos and can incorporate a social aspect as well through forums, blogs, chat rooms, etc. Asynchronous E-Learning is a natural extension of Synchronous E-Learning and while these two components of learning complement each other they can be used independently of each other. 

 Synchronous E-Learning is often used when on-site physical demonstrations are required or when the learner has to be qualified as having gained the level of knowledge originally set out in the learning objectives or a given curriculum. Synchronous E-Learning can also be employed when the benefits of social interaction such as in a classroom, workshop or webinar will benefit the learning process.

Asynchronous E-Learning is a part of that process; it breaks information down and makes it more easily digestible as a stand-alone presentation, learn at your own pace, discrete  segment of information that is required learning; or for information that is used as a building block for much more complex ideas and concepts. Asynchronous E-Learning is a natural extension of Synchronous E-Learning and while these two components of learning complement each other they can be used independently of each other.

Effective E-Learning, whether Synchronous or Asynchronous, emulates good teaching style and utilizes the attributes of the electronic medium and the best practices of learning, utilizing sound preparation, illustrative anecdotes, humour, personal experience and thought provoking insight to engage and inspire learners in an anytime, anywhere format (that’s the Asynchronous part.)

Ultimately E-Learning as a whole, whether Synchronous or Asynchronous allow for repeated and consistent deployment of well thought out knowledge without the day-to-day participation of an instructor. This adds significant cost savings, reduces teaching time, improves comprehension and standardizes the information to insure consistent delivery of knowledge. This does not mean that instructors are not used, it simply  means that the instructor or in most circumstances, group of instructors develop the content and then deploy it in a Synchronous E-Learning module that uses best practices teaching strategies for developing the content.

Asynchronous E-Learning uses the discrete building blocks of Synchronous E-learning to emulate a classroom setting more closely and communicate complex ideas that allow the learners to engage in a more Interactive dialogue with the instructor and with other learners. This process combines best practices of teaching and E-Learning because such presentations are repeated and greater care and support is given to the dynamic of learning in the Asynchronous learning process.  It is also expected that such curriculums, once developed offer a longer life cycle when the content is revised annually. It is my suggestion that Synchronous E-Learning will someday replace textbooks entirely and will be updated by organizations whose sole responsibility it is to maintain up to date information on learning topics, similar to text book publishers today.

I think it’s safe to say that E-Learning in any form is more than an amalgam of parameters, media and instructional design, it’s a learning environment that reflects the learning objectives, the nature of the content and the makeup of the audience.